BTC$80,260 -0.38%ETH$2,324 -0.24%USDT$1.00 +0.02%BNB$743 -0.74%SOL$101 -0.18%XRP$1.29 -1.79%ADA$0.20 -0.13%DOGE$0.08 +0.38%
Prices · CoinGecko

Decentralization Theory VS Decentralization Reality

Guest postsGuest post2 min read

Princeton computer scientist Arvind Narayanan has long studied and lectured on the themes of cryptocurrency and decentralization, dating back to 2013. However, on New Year's Eve, this renowned digital privacy specialist unleashed a withering broadside against the popular narrative about blockchain's role as a decentralizing force in society.

The Fundamental Flaws of Decentralization

In a multi-part tweetstorm, Narayanan deconstructed what he sees as the "leaps in logic" linking blockchain software to decentralization on a societal scale. He argues persuasively that technologies alone won't be enough to achieve the sort of decentralization that most crypto devotees pursue.

As Narayanan notes, the internet and web decentralized many things for good. But human ingenuity has again and again found ways to capture value and wield control, regardless of decentralization's early gains. Amazon illustrates this trend, having outdone Walmart by combining smooth online retail innovations with large centralized warehouses and streamlined supply chains.

This echoes perspectives from blockchain entrepreneur Joseph Lubin, who suggests decentralized platforms will only succeed as more developers are attracted to the space and led to build on decentralized infrastructures.

Measuring the Uneven Decentralization in Bitcoin and Ethereum

Gencer and his co-authors reported several findings:

The researchers found that neither Bitcoin nor Ethereum possesses strictly superior properties compared to the other.

The conclusions reached by Gencer and his colleagues have been heavily debated on social media.

The paper outlines the basic theory of the scalability challenge using a triangle, an idea Ocean Protocol founder Trent McConaghy also developed independently.

In a paper titled "Systemization of Knowledge," Bano evaluated and compared various consensus protocols, such as proof-of-work and proof-of-stake, to identify gaps in development.

Bitcoin's Mining Network Has Become More Decentralized

According to a February report by Canadian financial services firm Canaccord Genuity Group, Bitcoin has become more decentralized by several metrics, having been less decentralized in its early days based on hashrate distribution.

Canaccord notes that the HHI index is used to measure market concentration.

In mid-2014, the mining pool GHash.IO controlled roughly 50 percent of Bitcoin's total hashrate, leaving the network vulnerable to a potential 51 percent attack in which bad actors could rewrite transactions. In 2019, however, no individual mining pool commanded more than 20 percent of Bitcoin's hashrate, with five pools controlling between 10 and 20 percent each and the rest holding under 10 percent.

This increased competition prompted "Canaan Creative to sell its chips to a broader audience of miners that can effectively compete with Bitmain," according to the firm.

This column was written by an outside contributor. Views are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of Bit News Today.

TopicsDecentralizationProof-of-WorkProof-of-StakeCryptoCompare