Illusions: How The Crypto Market Centralized Itself
ExchangesBit News Today2 min read
The main selling point of decentralized exchanges is that, unlike better-known crypto trading platforms like Coinbase, Kraken or Binance, they don't require traders to store their money with a third party that can be hacked. Data gathered by Alethio over a two-week period revealed a different reality across several decentralized platforms.
Centralization in trading
For example, Alethio evaluated trading activity on Bancor. On the 0x protocol, 914 market makers facilitated 9,017 trades among 234 traders over the two weeks monitored by Alethio. In contrast, during the same period, Bancor – which uses smart contracts to provide decentralized liquidity – had a more concentrated market, handling a slightly larger volume: 9,691 token swaps by 1,147 traders. However, those trades were funneled through only 17 relayer startups.
This lack of participant diversity highlighted vulnerabilities in Bancor's network, as demonstrated by the actions it took after suffering a $13.5 million hack.
Given how relayers operate and handle compliance, it is difficult to describe this style of DEX as leaderless. Most of these relayers rely on their own proprietary software built on top of 0x rather than code that is fully open-source and publicly inspectable.
IDEX, developed by the fintech firm Aurora, facilitated a hefty 69,339 swaps between 12,400 traders during that same two-week period, more than any other analyzed DEX.
Regulatory hurdles
Swatt, a former co-founder of Coinsetter who later sold the company to Kraken, warned that managing compliance, security, and customer support presents major challenges for grassroots crypto models. News that Coinbase had bought decentralized exchange relayer Paradex in May provided decentralized exchange advocates with sobering lessons.
Then there's the little matter of how 0x's decentralized participants will handle compliance. All those independent relayers?
Crypto consultant Carlson advises a more focused definition of decentralization.
Traditional players enter custody
Custody has been a primary obstacle preventing more institutional investors from getting into digital currencies. Fidelity, an asset manager overseeing $2.5 trillion, is entering the sector with a digital assets business planned for launch in 2019. Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and an investment firm founded by billionaire former partner Mike Novogratz are backing crypto custodian BitGo Holdings Inc. as clients seek secure storage, an endorsement that could help BitGo attract institutions and wealthy investors.

