Great Britain: the presumption of guilt for crypto entrepreneurs
RegulationBit News Today2 min read
Up to the end of 2018 British authorities gave cryptocurrency no single legal definition: the tax office, the financial regulator and the Treasury each described it for their own purposes, while Gibraltar and Malta wrote dedicated laws. The table tracks those decisions, which left UK founders and holders to argue case by case how their coins should be treated.
| Date | Authority | Decision | What it meant for crypto businesses |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Mar 2014 | HMRC | Mining bitcoin and swapping it for pounds placed outside VAT | Merchants paid in bitcoin still charge 20% VAT on the coin's sterling value at the time of sale |
| 3 Mar 2014 | HMRC | Corporation, income and capital gains tax left to assessment case by case | Companies record bitcoin gains and losses in their accounts under ordinary corporation tax rules |
| 3 Mar 2014 | HMRC | Restated that betting winnings are untaxed and betting losses are not deductible | Left open whether some coin speculation could be argued to be gambling |
| 1 Jan 2018 | Gibraltar Financial Services Commission | DLT Regulatory Framework took effect | Firms holding or moving other people's value via DLT need a DLT Provider authorisation and must meet nine principles |
| Mar 2018 | Chancellor of the Exchequer | Cryptoassets Taskforce formed from HM Treasury, the FCA and the Bank of England | First joint review of crypto policy by the three UK bodies |
| Jul 2018 | Parliament of Malta | Passed the Malta Digital Innovation Authority Act, the ITAS Act and the Virtual Financial Asset Act, unanimously at second reading | Silvio Schembri promised legal certainty; Binance, OKEx and BitPay had already set up on the island |
| 29 Oct 2018 | Cryptoassets Taskforce | Final report published | FCA to consult on perimeter guidance and on a possible ban on selling crypto derivatives to retail clients |
| 29 Oct 2018 | HM Treasury | Assigned transposition of the EU Fifth Money Laundering Directive | Anti-money-laundering duties to be extended to crypto activity |
| 1 Nov 2018 | Malta Financial Services Authority | Virtual Financial Assets Act in force | Licences for VFA service providers and rules for public token offerings |
| Dec 2018 | HMRC | Guidance for individuals: most holders count as investors paying capital gains tax | Income tax only where activity reaches the level of a financial trade, which HMRC called exceptional |
| Dec 2018 | HMRC | Buying and selling tokens is not gambling; bitcoin is not money for direct tax | Closed the winnings argument; tokens are pooled by type, as with shares |
| Dec 2018 | HMRC | Income tax and National Insurance on tokens received as pay, from mining or from airdrops | Guidance for companies and other businesses promised separately |
Sources: PCWorld, Sovereign Group, Faegre Drinker, Bitcoin Magazine, Elliptic, Pinsent Masons.



