BTC$80,260 -0.38%ETH$2,324 -0.24%USDT$1.00 +0.02%BNB$743 -0.74%SOL$101 -0.18%XRP$1.29 -1.79%ADA$0.20 -0.13%DOGE$0.08 +0.38%
Prices · CoinGecko

ETF: The False Messiah Of The Digital Economy?

RegulationBit News Today2 min read

Cryptocurrency markets sank to fresh lows for the year on Wednesday after the Securities and Exchange Commission dampened optimism for a bitcoin-backed VanEck exchange-traded fund.

In a broad selloff across various digital currencies, the total market capitalization of the virtual currency market declined, per Coinmarketcap.com, to around $230 billion.

Bitcoin dropped 5.6% to $6,484 at 8:19 a.m. in New York, following an earlier decline of 7%. Ripple slumped 10% while Ether and Litecoin's value dropped by at least 4.7%. By 10:05 a.m., bitcoin had lost 8.5% in value.

The news from the SEC appears to have been the catalyst for the selloff. Bitcoin subsequently slid over 11% to under $6,300, falling far short of its record peak of more than $19,000 reached in December 2017.

The SEC established September 30, 2018, as its deadline to approve, reject, or begin proceedings to consider rejecting a rule change proposed by Cboe Global Markets Inc. to list an ETF from VanEck Associates Corp. and SolidX Partners Inc. If granted approval, the fund would become the first bitcoin ETF.

The firms submitted their application in June, triggering an active public comment period where the crypto community voiced widespread support. Proposals from ProShares, Direxion and GraniteShares bring the total number of bitcoin-related funds being considered by the SEC to 10, although none are "physical" like the VanEck/SolidX offering. The regulator is permitted to delay these decisions for up to 240 days following publication in the Register.

The regulator's decision to delay the VanEck ETF comes just a month after they rejected a very similar proposal from the Winklevoss twins. Some had hoped the VanEck ETF would be more likely to gain approval, in part due to an intended high minimum share price that would discourage retail investors.

While the Winklevoss ETF, which would have traded under the ticker COIN, was structured as a grantor trust and used the Winklevoss's Gemini Exchange to set prices, the VanEck ETF would be backed by actual cryptocurrencies, not futures. Unlike prior bids, the VanEck and SolidX proposal includes insurance to protect the trust's bitcoin holdings against theft or loss.

Just over a month earlier, the SEC voted 3-1 to reject a bitcoin ETF proposed by the Winklevoss twins over concerns about price manipulation. Greater institutional involvement would help ease several of the SEC's concerns about the bitcoin market.

TopicsETFVanEck-SolidXWinklevoss twinsPanthera capitalRobert KiyosakiDaniil DanchenkoCatherine Lange