Enterprise Blockchain Projects: Six Common Missteps
TechnologyBit News Today2 min read
Gartner's June 2019 list of blockchain planning errors, retold as six missteps by Crypto News in October 2019, maps closely onto the corporate ledger projects that stalled or closed between 2022 and 2023. The table pairs each misstep with what tends to break and a documented case, from the TradeLens shipping platform to the ASX settlement overhaul.
| Misstep | What goes wrong | Real example | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Misreading what blockchain is | Pilots use only the distributed ledger to log data and leave consensus, tokenisation and smart contracts unused | Gartner found most projects never moved past early experimentation; only 11% of CIOs had deployed blockchain or planned to soon | Gartner 2019 CIO Agenda Survey, 3,000+ CIOs |
| Assuming the technology is production-ready | The platform market is fragmented and most products are too immature for large-scale use | ASX paused its ledger-based CHESS replacement, built by Digital Asset, in November 2022 and booked a A$245-255 million pre-tax write-off | Gartner, June 2019; Accenture review for ASX, 2022 |
| Confusing a protocol with a business solution | A working application also needs an interface, business logic, data storage and integration with other systems | Crypto News put the ledger at no more than ten percent of total development effort in a broad project | Gartner, June 2019; Crypto News, October 2019 |
| Treating blockchain as a database | The ledger supports only create and read, not update or delete, trading data flexibility for decentralisation | Gartner analysts said a conventional data management system can be the better choice in some cases | Gartner, June 2019 |
| Assuming interoperability already exists | Most platforms were still being designed, so links between chains were hard to build | Crypto News warned that platforms built in 2018 might not work with another vendor's stack a year later; Gartner called vendor claims marketing | Gartner, June 2019; Crypto News, October 2019 |
| Treating smart contracts as a solved problem | Contract code runs on every node of the network, which strains scaling and management | Gartner advised small experiments rather than full rollout, expecting maturity within two to three years of mid-2019 | Gartner, June 2019 |
| Ignoring governance | Public chains such as Bitcoin and Ethereum govern code but rarely human incentives; consortia must agree rules | Maersk and IBM announced the end of TradeLens on 29 November 2022, citing a lack of full industry collaboration despite 150+ participants | Gartner, June 2019; Cointelegraph, November 2022 |
| Launching a consortium without lasting funding | Bank-owned networks depend on shareholders agreeing to keep paying until volumes arrive | we.trade, owned by 12 European banks and IBM and run on Hyperledger Fabric, began insolvency proceedings in June 2022 after failing to raise new money | Global Trade Review, June 2022 |
| Letting rollout slip while adoption stays thin | Missed launch dates erode backers' patience before the network reaches scale | Marco Polo, built on R3 Corda with 30+ member banks, missed early-2019 and Q2 2020 targets; liquidators were appointed in February 2023 with debts of about 5.2 million euros | Global Trade Review, February 2023 |
Sources: Gartner, IT Brief, Crypto News, iTnews, Cointelegraph, Global Trade Review.
