BTC$80,260 -0.38%ETH$2,324 -0.24%USDT$1.00 +0.02%BNB$743 -0.74%SOL$101 -0.18%XRP$1.29 -1.79%ADA$0.20 -0.13%DOGE$0.08 +0.38%
Prices · CoinGecko

Virtual Currency in France Have the Same Rights as Puppets

CryptoBit News Today2 min read

On April 26, 2018, the Conseil d'État, France's highest administrative court, determined that units of bitcoin constitute intangible personal property. The court emphasized that cryptocurrencies are movable assets and fall under the French tax code provision for capital gains on movable property.

French Court Rules Bitcoin Qualifies as Intangible Personal Property

In the eyes of the law

Under Article 516 of the French Civil Code, the Conseil d'État determined that units of bitcoin constitute "intangible personal properties". In its reasoning, the Conseil d'État addressed key administrative guidelines:

First, the court ruled that the 2014 guidelines issued by the French tax authorities improperly classified occasional cryptocurrency sales. In their petition to the Conseil d'État, five plaintiffs argued that proceeds from cryptocurrency sales should be taxed as intangible personal property gains and called for the 2014 administrative notice to be annulled.

Changes for crypto traders and investors

Under the personal property capital gains regime, gains are subject to a flat 19% tax rate plus social levies of 17.2% for 2018, amounting to an overall rate of 36.2%. This represents a substantial reduction, as non-commercial profits were previously taxable at up to 45% via income tax plus 17.2% CSG for top-bracket taxpayers.

Coin holders will declare eligible gains under the personal property capital gains regime instead of non-commercial profits. A notable aspect of this tax regime is that capital gains are fully exempt for total sale proceeds under 5,000 euros.

Mining and habitual trading remain exceptions

Cryptocurrency gains do not receive identical treatment in all cases – there are specific exceptions. If someone trades cryptocurrency on a habitual and regular basis, their gains will continue to fall into the BIC category. Cryptocurrency earnings are also liable for BNC taxation when they are not investment returns but rather compensation for a taxpayer's involvement in creating or operating the cryptocurrency.

This is especially relevant for mining operations.

Financial and regulatory implications

French regulatory and monetary authorities, including the AMF and the Banque de France, have issued repeated warnings regarding investments in bitcoin. In 2017, the price of bitcoin rose on exchanges from under $1,000 early in the year to nearly $20,000 in late December before dropping at year's end, and it traded at around $8,800 on the Thursday of the ruling.

Late in 2017, French financial regulators and the government issued multiple warnings against investing in bitcoin as its valuation surged.

The classification adopted by the court follows positions taken by the AMF and the Banque de France, making it possible for bitcoin to serve as an underlying asset in financial contracts. The decision may provide legal certainty for French financial professionals, enabling them to market contracts with bitcoin as the underlying asset.