BTC$80,260 -0.38%ETH$2,324 -0.24%USDT$1.00 +0.02%BNB$743 -0.74%SOL$101 -0.18%XRP$1.29 -1.79%ADA$0.20 -0.13%DOGE$0.08 +0.38%
Prices · CoinGecko

Federal Reserve Branch Confirms Bitcoin Futures Launch Importance

CryptoBit News Today2 min read

The San Francisco Federal Reserve on Monday, May 7, 2018 released a report attributing the roughly 50-percent decline in bitcoin prices from its $20,000 late-2017 peak to the launch of bitcoin futures. Written by four researchers, the study concludes that the surge and eventual collapse in bitcoin's price that year was driven by the introduction of a futures market for betting against its value.

In an Economic Letter, researchers from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco and a professor from Stanford University analyzed bitcoin's price movements in the months leading up to and immediately following the launches of Cboe and CME bitcoin futures in December 2017.

Years of Ascent, Months of Descent

In the years between its 2009 launch and the middle of 2017, bitcoin's price remained under $4,000. However, from February 2017 to its December peak, its price climbed exponentially to nearly $20,000. Bitcoin reached its highest price on the day that bitcoin futures began trading on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME).

The report notes that the close timing between the debut of futures trading and the sharp rise and fall of bitcoin in late 2017 was not a coincidence.

The researchers contend that bitcoin’s rapid run until its peak on December 17, 2017 was due to a one-sided market for the cryptocurrency energized by investors who were optimistic about the digital coin's future. This pushed the price to soar while leaving no instrument for those with an opposing view to short the market.

“We suggest that the rapid rise of the price of bitcoin and its decline following the issuance of futures on the CME is consistent with pricing dynamics — Once derivatives markets become sufficiently deep, short-selling pressure from pessimists leads to a sharp decline in value,” the researchers state.

Cboe vs. CME

The report explains that Cboe had opened its bitcoin futures market a week earlier on December 10 before CME’s entry. However, average daily trading volume the month after was approximately six times larger once CME joined the market. Cboe’s market saw thin trading until CME, by virtue of its entry into the market, deepened overall liquidity.

Additionally, while two earlier price drops in 2017 recovered to previous levels in about a month, bitcoin had still not returned to its pre-futures peak by late April 2018.

Bearish Pressures

The report also draws on economic research by Fostel and Geanakoplos (2012) regarding price dynamics when new financial instruments are introduced. The authors argue that these price dynamics “are consistent with the rise and collapse of the home financing market in the 2000s, as explained in Fostel and Geanakoplos (2012).”

This highlights how the introduction of derivatives in bitcoin mirrored the turning point observed in the complex mortgage-backed securities market during the 2000s.

Still, the Fed’s study notes these dynamics were not driven by overall broad equity movements like the Standard & Poor’s 500 stock index.