SEC vs DEX: Two Lessons To Learn From EtherDelta Case
AnalysisBit News Today2 min read
In 2018, the Securities and Exchange Commission announced settled charges against Zachary Coburn, the founder of the digital token trading platform EtherDelta, for operating an unregistered national securities exchange. This was the SEC's first enforcement action targeting a digital token trading platform operating as an unregistered securities exchange.
The 31-year-old resident of Chicago created EtherDelta in July 2016, after first launching an online options trading platform called EtherOpt in March 2016.
The Mechanism of EtherDelta's Smart Contract Platform
EtherDelta was an online platform for conducting secondary market trades of ERC-20 tokens, a type of blockchain-based token often issued during Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs). Launched by Coburn on July 12, 2016, EtherDelta's website provided a user-friendly interface to the platform, similar in appearance to conventional online securities trading platforms. According to the SEC, EtherDelta's core business operations were automated by its smart contract, which was programmed in the Solidity language and deployed to the Ethereum blockchain on July 8, 2016.
EtherDelta's order book, which stored all trade orders, resided on a centralized server maintained by the platform. Orders were matched and executed via the EtherDelta smart contract, which performed certain checks and managed the trade. The trading process paired a maker's cryptographically signed intent to trade with a taker's cryptographically signed intent to trade. Unlike custodial exchanges such as Coinbase and Gemini, EtherDelta never held accounts for its users' funds.
SEC Ruling on EtherDelta's Exchange Status
The SEC's order held that EtherDelta met the criteria of a "national securities exchange" as defined by federal securities laws. During its relevant period (July 2016 to December 2017), EtherDelta was not registered with the SEC and did not operate under any exemption. The platform brought together and executed orders, providing the operational backbone and user interface of a traditional online securities exchange.
Coburn, as the platform's founder, wrote and deployed the smart contract and maintained control over the exchange's operations. Hinkes observed that this demonstrates that an exchange utilizing a distributed network of nodes rather than a centralized server will not be treated any differently.
The Regulatory Headwinds for Decentralized Exchanges
The SEC took action without clarifying which specific tokens traded on EtherDelta qualified as securities, leaving ambiguous which assets could trigger regulatory enforcement.
Preston Byrne, a partner at the law firm Byrne & Storm, P.C., emphasized that American securities laws will be enforced regardless of whether an operator sold the business or ran it in the past.
The SEC's action suggests that decentralized exchanges, even those that do not charge trading fees, may fall under the SEC's definition of an unregistered securities exchange if they provide the necessary operational infrastructure. As a consequence, EtherDelta will be compelled to entirely restructure its operations, and all other decentralized exchanges will also need to adjust.


