Russian Arbitration Court: Cryptocurrency Can Be Used in Insolvency Proceedings After All
RegulationBit News Today1 min read
On 15 May 2018, the full text of a decree from the 9th Arbitrazh Appellate Court was published, recognizing cryptocurrency as property within the scope of Russian civil law. In its decree, the Court of Appeal explicitly identified cryptocurrency as an independent asset class, even in the absence of specific regulatory frameworks. The court's decision came in relation to a landmark case, where a lower court had initially refused to recognize the legal status of cryptocurrency in insolvency proceedings.
The case involved Russian citizen Ilya Tsarkov, who filed for bankruptcy in October 2017 after owing more than 18 million rubles to Rikas Finance under a suretyship contract. Despite Tsarkov's admission of holding Bitcoin, the Moscow Arbitration Court initially dismissed a request by his financial manager, Alexey Leonov, to include the contents of Tsarkov's crypto wallet in the bankruptcy estate.
Key Arguments and Decision
The Moscow court's rejection was primarily based on the finding that the Russian legal framework did not provide a definition of cryptocurrency or outline requirements for its circulation. The court argued that without clear legal recognition, cryptocurrency could not be included in the debtor's bankruptcy assets. This perspective was also echoed by Tsarkov's legal representative, who asserted that cryptocurrency was not part of the Russian Civil Code and represented information that could not be included in the bankruptcy mass.
However, the 9th Arbitrazh Appellate Court took a different view. It recognized that while Russian laws did not offer a statutory definition for cryptocurrency, the scope of property rights in Article 128 of the Civil Code includes "other assets" and applies to non-excluded holdings. In essence, unless specifically restricted by federal statutes, cryptocurrencies fall under the scope of general property legislation. Thus, the court ruled that Ilya Tsarkov was obliged to hand over the key to his crypto wallet to the insolvency practitioner.



