Are Security Token Offerings Good for Blockchain Crowdfunding Business?
AnalysisBit News Today2 min read
Security token offerings grew out of the 2017 ICO boom as a way to sell blockchain tokens inside US securities rules instead of around them. The tables follow the main deals and regulatory steps from the DAO ruling to the first SEC-qualified public token sale, showing that the model could raise serious money but restricted who could buy and how soon tokens could change hands.
| Date | Issuer or regulator | Step | Figure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | The DAO | Token sale for a decentralized investment vehicle on Ethereum | About $150 million raised |
| 3 April 2017 | Blockchain Capital | Offers BCAP tokens on Ethereum carrying a non-voting economic interest in its Digital Liquid Venture Fund | Up to $10 million |
| April 2017 | Blockchain Capital | Sale open only to accredited US buyers and non-US persons abroad, under Rule 506(c) and Regulation S | No more than 99 US investors |
| 25 July 2017 | SEC | Section 21(a) report finds DAO tokens were securities that should have been registered, using the Howey test | Three-part test: money, common enterprise, profit from others' work |
| 6 August 2018 | tZERO | Security token offering closes | $134 million from more than 1,000 investors worldwide |
| 12 October 2018 | tZERO | Tokens minted into a custodial wallet and locked until 10 January 2019 | 90-day holding period |
| 10 July 2019 | Blockstack | First digital-asset offering qualified by the SEC under Regulation A | Target of $28 million |
| July 2019 | Blockstack | Cost of getting the offering qualified | About $2 million and roughly one year |
US routes used by token issuers
| Route | Who can buy | Key limit |
|---|---|---|
| Rule 506(c), Regulation D | Accredited investors only, with status checked by the issuer | No dollar cap; public advertising allowed |
| Regulation S | Non-US persons, with offers made outside the United States | No sales to US buyers |
| Regulation A, Tier 1 (2019 rules) | General public, issuers based in the US or Canada | $20 million per 12 months; state registration needed |
| Regulation A, Tier 2 (2019 rules) | General public; non-accredited buyers capped at 10% of the greater of income or net worth | $50 million per 12 months; audited financial statements |
| Accredited investor test | Individuals meeting a wealth or income bar | $1 million net worth or $200,000 annual income |
| Exchange Act Section 12(g) | Issuers whose holder base grows large | Registration triggered at 2,000 holders or 500 non-accredited holders, with over $10 million in assets |
Sources: Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, NewsBTC, Mondo Visione, Decrypt, Legal 500, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
