Cryptocurrencies in Times of Crisis: Will They Someday Become a Global Safe Haven?
TechnologyBit News Today2 min read
One of bitcoin's primary narratives depicts it as "digital gold," functioning as a store of value in periods of economic instability.
In Bitcoin's early days, Bitcoin proponents pitched the cryptocurrency as a haven from instability. In 2013, bitcoin was hailed as the "asset of the future," representing decentralized value, a protest against powerlessness, and a way for savers to limit their exposure to central bank measures. The cryptocurrency's issuance schedule, with a hard cap of 21 million bitcoins, made it comparable to a commodity like gold.
"Savings-based money like gold or bitcoin becomes more attractive as the Fed and Washington lawmakers push toward fiscal extremes," observers argued. Indeed, Bitcoin fans have long treated the cryptocurrency as something worth owning in times of market chaos, with that message baked into its genesis block itself.
Yet questions persist about whether bitcoin truly behaves as a safe-haven asset during times of financial distress. Evidence is mixed.
Bitcoin and geopolitical uncertainty
Bitcoin, too, has benefited from geopolitical turmoil. While seen as a risk-on asset by Silicon Valley venture investors, bitcoin can serve as a risk-off asset for people enduring a currency crisis, with adoption in Venezuela often cited as an example.
But Bitcoin's relationship with geopolitical uncertainty might not be as clear-cut. Following the U.S. killing of a top Iranian official, a sharp rise in bitcoin's price reignited the debate over whether the cryptocurrency can function as a safe haven like gold during geopolitical turmoil. The cryptocurrency's price spiked nearly 10 percent in the days following the U.S. killing of Iranian general Qassem Soleimani, something market watcher Michael Novogratz described as a bullish case for gold and bitcoin.
But not all analysts were convinced. Adam Vettese noted that the price reaction might have simply been "a technical move off support at $7,000."
And across broader financial turmoil
Bitcoin's price performance during the COVID-19 crisis led to interpretations that it did not function as a safe haven after all.
During that market downturn, an asset designed to be a safe haven fell by 31 percent while the S&P dropped by a quarter. Even so, traditional safe havens sold off alongside bitcoin, leaving the cryptocurrency trading cheaply against the U.S. dollar while its fundamental value proposition remained unchanged.
Observers noted that an asset subject to an intraday plunge of more than 40 percent is unlikely to ever be viewed seriously as a safe haven.
Where Bitcoin stands as a safe haven
Instead of decoupling, bitcoin saw its daily correlation with the S&P shift from slightly negative in February to 0.6 in March.
After March 12, bitcoin began displaying a stronger correlation with gold while its correlation with the S&P 500 retreated into non-correlated territory.
