The Ancient Tragedy in the Digital Market: EOS Reversed the Transaction and Created Environment for C
TechnologyBit News Today1 min read
An EOS arbitrator reversed confirmed transactions, as revealed on November 9th, and froze the funds, a post on Reddit said. The incident, which appears in case number #ECAF00000023, involved a user who reported their account credentials and funds compromised by a phishing attack.
An EOS arbitrator resolved the victim's dispute by reversing the transactions. According to the ruling, arbitrator Ben Gates, overseen by Moti Tabulo, ruled "the account EOS should be returned to the claimant immediately, and the funds sent out from this account should be frozen and returned. The user's ownership of the original ERC-20 account was proven by signing a memo specified by the forum.
Prior to this incident, in June 2018, the EOS Core Arbitration Forum (ECAF) had targeted accounts compromised by other phishing attempts, with the 21 EOS block producers ordered to not process transactions from 27 different wallet addresses as an emergency protection measure.
EOS Immutability Questioned
Critics view such orders as evidence that EOS is subject to government-like control rather than functioning as a decentralized network.
The EOS blockchain is governed by an elected set of 21 Block Producers (BPs) who hold the primary delegated consensus power, and can censor transactions, which differs from the decentralized approach of Bitcoin's PoW.
In benchmark testing results published on November 1, 2018, blockchain testing firm Whiteblock reported that block producers can alter data on the distributed network, asserting that EOS relies on a flawed model that is not truly decentralized.
EOS critics argue its high transaction throughput comes at the expense of true decentralization, since governance lies in the hands of a few.
